Best Italian Restaurant in Lake City

Scratch-Made Sauces. Hand-Rolled Meatballs. Fresh Pizza. Serving Lake City & Branford.

We Are Located in Historic Downtown Lake City

Our Lake City location at 297 N Marion Ave sits in the heart of downtown, surrounded by brick sidewalks, local shops, and a welcoming small-town atmosphere. Whether you’re coming from nearby neighborhoods or passing through the city center, Our Place Pizzeria & Italian Ristorante is easy to find and always ready to serve.

Find Us

Hours & Location

Address: 297 N Marion Ave, Lake City, FL 32055, United States Phone: +1 386-984-5411 Hours: Monday–Wednesday: 11 AM–9 PM Thursday–Saturday: 11 AM–10 PM Sunday: 11 AM–9 PM

Get Directions

Top-Rated Italian Dining in Downtown Lake City: What Locals Say

Our Place Pizzeria and Italian Ristorante on Marion Avenue captures glowing customer sentiment for its authentic flavor and vibrant downtown energy. Semantic analysis of local Google reviews reveals overwhelming social proof celebrating the signature handcrafted pizzas and excellent made-from-scratch Italian classics. Guests routinely praise the wonderful service, welcoming family atmosphere, and the popular 2-for-1 cocktails, making it the premier neighborhood gathering place.

Featured

View menu

Welcome to Our Place Pizzeria & Italian Ristorante

A casual, family-style Italian restaurant serving Lake City and Branford, featuring an extensive menu of pizza, pasta dishes, and burgers made for everyone to enjoy.

A Menu Worth Coming Back For

From brick oven pizza with our homemade tomato sauce to Seafood Ravioli stuffed with crab and lobster — every dish is made from scratch.

Order Online

Hand-Rolled Meatballs Since Day OneThe Hot Italian Sub With Marinara — Trust UsPizza Worth Driving Across Town ForSave Room for the Limoncello CakeGarlic Knots Fresh Out of the OvenYour Place Is Our PlaceHand-Rolled Meatballs Since Day OneThe Hot Italian Sub With Marinara — Trust UsPizza Worth Driving Across Town ForSave Room for the Limoncello CakeGarlic Knots Fresh Out of the OvenYour Place Is Our Place

Everything Made From Scratch

Our sauces simmer in-house, the meatballs are hand-rolled, and the garlic knots come straight out of the oven. That part hasn't changed.

See Our Menu

Something for Everyone

Sip & Repeat

Find Us on Marion Ave & Branford

We’re right in the heart of historic downtown Lake City — sidewalk tables, string lights, and a front door that’s always open. You can also visit our Branford location for the same warm hospitality and Italian favorites.

Plan Your Visit

Catering Made Easy

Bring the taste of authentic Italian cooking to your next gathering. From scratch-made sauces and hand-rolled meatballs to fresh pizza and classic pasta dishes, our catering menu is perfect for parties, events, and family celebrations in Lake City and Branford.

Get Catering Info

Our Place Is Your Place

On Marion Ave in downtown Lake City, we make everything from scratch — the sauces, the meatballs, the garlic knots — and we mean it when we say welcome.

Our Place is my favorite road trip stop from Atlanta to Big Bend. Love their food, especially their pizzas. Today I got the Cabrese pizza with grilled chicken and it was friggin’ dee-licious!!

Michael K.

Second time her got the bbq pizza awesome, Ty waited on us he was great will ask for him next time. ordered the large Hawaiian pizza it was delicious took half home for later.

Tuesday B.

Had a Greek salad and a very, very good pizza. My wife and I eat pizza all over honor travels and this was one of the best. Thanks for the military discount too, much appreciated.

Joe H.

Fantastic food!!! This was our first time eating there and we were very impressed. We were greeted at the door by friendly staff and we were quickly seated. The food was really good with fresh ingredients and the serving sizes are enormous.

Gator M.